Brotherhood Mutual Insurance

Over 90 years ago, Brotherhood Mutual began as a Mennonite aid association to provide basic insurance protection to churches and church members. Today, we remain dedicated to our Christian heritage by focusing all our efforts on the unique needs of Christian ministries.

Brotherhood Mutual provides comprehensive property, liability, vehicle, workers' compensation, and foreign travel insurance products and risk management services to ministries such as:
  • Churches
  • Christian Schools K-12
  • Day Care Centers
  • Camps, Retreats, and Conference Centers
  • Christian Colleges and Universities
  • District and Administrative Offices
  • Youth Ministries and Organizations

Brotherhood Mutual serves ministries through constantly updating and improving our coverages to meet the complex and changing demands of today's ministries. In addition to our innovative coverages, our customers receive personal attention and prompt service. According to our claims satisfaction survey, 98% of policyholders were satisfied with our claims handling.

Here's what a few pastors have to say...

        "Best insurance company we ever dealt with. The adjuster offered to come and look at the damage when most roads were blocked by a record snowfall. We are recommending Brotherhood to other churches."
– Pastor Melvin Webb, Calvary Holiness Church, Shepherdsville, KY

        "Your personal attention to helping us with our insurance needs, problems and questions has long been acknowledged by our administration." – J. Roy Fuller, Pittsburgh District, Church of the Nazarene, Butler, PA

        "Your representative not only helped us with our claim but went out of his way to help us with suggestions for preventing future problems and getting this one fixed."
– William Schweikhard, deacon, Northridge Church of Christ, Shawnee, OK

        "We are very pleased to be covered by your policy. We could not ask for a better company to work with. Thank you so much for everything."
– Steve Brown, church clerk, Sandstone Congregational Church, Spring Arbor, MI

To learn more about our products and services, visit www.brotherhoodmutual.com or call 800.333.3735.

Related lnformation:

YES! I'm interested.

Complete this form to request info from Brotherhood Mutual Insurance.

Contact Info
6400 Brotherhood Way
Fort Wayne
IN
United States
45825
260-482-8668
X 5874
260